Open Access Open Access  Restricted Access Subscription Access

Why establishing a Credible and Legitimate Transitional Justice Model in conjunction with Democratic Reforms is Necessary for Long-term Peace and Stability in Uganda

Jeremy Sarkin

Abstract


Uganda is a specific focus of international criminal justice at present because of issues relating the International Criminal Court, and specifically the trial of the Lord’s Resistance Army commander Dominic Ongwen, which began in late 2016. In this context, this article reviews domestic developments in Uganda over the past few years to determine what Uganda ought to do about the past, and why the time is right for democratic reforms and transitional justice to occur in the country. It examines the processes Uganda has set up recently to determine when and how its past ought to be confronted, including a government inter-ministerial working group that has been dealing with transitional justice matters. The article considers why dealing with the past in Uganda, combined with democratic transformation, is a necessity, and why Uganda, at least in theory, has been embarking on a process to deal with the past. It examines the atrocities that have occurred in Uganda to examine why dealing with the past is essential to obtaining peace and stability. The article briefly examines Uganda’s two previous truth commissions to determine what should be avoided in a future process and what procedural and substantive steps could be taken to ensure a viable and successful transitional justice model combined with democratic reforms.


Keywords


Uganda; transitional justice; democratic reforms; human rights; peace; stability

Full Text:

PDF

References


Almqvist, J and Esposito, C, The Role of Courts in Transitional Justice: Voices from Latin America and Spain (Routledge 2013).

Amin, S, Austrian, A, Chau, M, Glazer, K, Green, E, Stewart, D and Stoner, M, ‘The Adolescent Girls Vulnerability Index: Guiding Strategic Investment in Uganda’ (Population Council 2013).

Amnesty International, ‘Amnesty International Annual Report’ (AI Publications 1979).

Amnesty International, ‘Uganda: Six Years after Amin, Tortures, Killing, Disappearances’ (1985) accessed 22 June 2015.

Amnesty International, ‘Uganda: The Human Rights Record 1986–1989’ (1989).

Anyeko, K, Baines, E, Komakech, E, Ojok, B, Ogora, LO and Victor, L, ‘The Cooling of Hearts’: Community Truth-telling in Northern Uganda’ (2012) 13(1) Human Rights Review 107–124.

Apuuli, KP, ‘The Prospect of establishing a Truth-telling and Reconciliation Commission in Uganda’ (2013) 10 US–China Law Review 596-619.

Arnould, V, ‘Transitional Justice and Democracy in Uganda: Between Impetus and Instrumentalisation’ (2015) 9(3) Journal of Eastern African Studies 354–374.

Atkinson, R, ‘Realists in Juba’? An Analysis of the Juba Peace Talks’ in T Allen and K Vlassenroot, The Lord’s Resistance Army: Myth and Reality (Zed Books 2010) 205–222.

Baines, E, ‘Spirits and Social Reconstruction after Mass Violence: Rethinking Transitional Justice’ (2010) 109(36) African Affairs 409–430.

Baines, EK, ‘Complex Political Perpetrators: Reflections on Dominic Ongwen’ (2009) 47(2) The Journal of Modern African Studies 163–191.

Baker, B, ‘Conflict and African Police Culture: The Cases of Uganda, Rwanda and, Sierra Leone’ in M Marks, M O’Neil and N Singh (eds), Police Occupational Culture: New Debates and Directions (Elsevier Science 2007) 321–347.

Bamidele, O, ‘“I’m Not Leaving, I’m Not Afraid”: (Re) Visiting the Dysfunctional Systems of Justice on Gender-Based Violence (GBV) in Uganda’ (2016) 12(1) Democracy and Security 23–43.

Behrend, H, Alice Lakwena and the Holy Spirits: War in Northern Uganda, 1985–97 (University of Wisconsin Press 1999).

Boas, M and Hatloy, A, ‘Poor, Terrorised and Internally Displaced: The Humanitarian Situation in Northern Uganda’ (2006) 36 Humanitarian Exchange 22.

Bottigliero, I, Redress for Victims of Crimes Under International Law (Springer 2013).

Branch, A, Displacing Human Rights: War and Intervention in Northern Uganda (Oxford University Press 2011). https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199782086.001.0001.

Ciorciari, JD and Franzblau, JM, ‘Hidden Files: Archival Sharing, Accountability, and the Right to the Truth’ (2014) 46(1) Columbia Human Rights Law Review 1–84.

Clark, P, ‘Bringing Them All Back Home: The Challenges of DDR and Transitional Justice in Contexts of Displacement in Rwanda and Uganda’ (2014) 27(2) Journal of Refugee Studies 234–259.

Claussen, J, Lotsberg, R, Nkutu, A and Nordby, E, Appraisal of the Peace Recovery and Development Plan for Northern Uganda (Norad 2008).

Corbin, JN, ‘Returning Home: Resettlement of Formerly Abducted Children in Northern Uganda’ (2008) 32(2) Disasters 316–335.

Day, CR, ‘The Fates of Rebels: Insurgencies in Uganda’ (2011) 43(4) Comparative Politics 439–458.

Decker, AC, ‘Sometime You may leave Your Husband in Karuma Falls or in the Forest There: A Gendered History of Disappearance in Idi Amin's Uganda, 1971–79’ (2013) 7(1) Journal of Eastern African Studies 125–142.

Doom, R and Vlassenroot, K, ‘Kony’s Message: A New Koine? The Lord's Resistance Army in Northern Uganda’ (1999) 98(390) African Affairs 5–36.

Dulani, B, ‘Democracy Movements as Bulwarks against Presidential Usurpation of Power: Lessons from the Third-Term Bids in Malawi, Namibia, Uganda and Zambia’ (2011) 20 Stichproben Vienna Journal of African Studies 115–139.

Editorial Staff, ‘MPs Appeal to Gov’t on War Injustice’ New Vision Uganda (Kampala, 2 December 2014) accessed 27 September 2016.

Egeland, J, ‘A Ugandan Tragedy’ Washington Post (Washington, 10 November 2004).

Esuruku, RS, ‘Beyond Masculinity: Gender, Conflict and Post-conflict Reconstruction in Northern Uganda’ (2011) 4(1) Journal of Science and Sustainable Development 25–40.

Field, SM, ‘UN Security Council Resolutions concerning Children affected by Armed Conflict: In Whose “Best Interest”?’ (2013) 21(1) The International Journal of Children's Rights 127–161. https://doi.org/10.1163/15718182-5680023.

Finnström, S, ‘In and Out of Culture Fieldwork in War-torn Uganda’ (2001) 21(3) Critique of Anthropology 247–258.

Finnström, S, ‘Wars of the Past and War in the Present: The Lord's Resistance Movement/Army in Uganda’ (2006) 76(2) Africa 200–220.

Fisher, J, ‘When It pays to be a “Fragile State”: Uganda’s use and abuse of a Dubious Concept’ (2014) 35(2) Third World Quarterly 316–332.

Fiske, L and Shackel, R, ‘Gender, Poverty and Violence: Transitional Justice Responses to Converging Processes of Domination of Women in Eastern DRC, Northern Uganda and Kenya’ (2015) 51 Women’s Studies International Forum 110–117.

Freeland, V, ‘Rebranding the State: Uganda’s Strategic use of the International Criminal Court’ (2015) 46(2) Development and Change 293–319.

G8 Foreign Ministers Meeting, ‘Declaration of G8 Foreign Ministers on the Rule of Law’ (2015) accessed 19 May 2016.

Gersony, R, The Anguish of Northern Uganda: Result of a Field-based Assessment of the Civil Conflicts in Northern Uganda (USAID Mission 1997).

Hinton, AL, Transitional Justice: Global Mechanisms and Local Realities after Genocide and Mass Violence (Rutgers University Press 2011).

Hopwood, J, ‘Women’s Land Claims in the Acholi Region of Northern Uganda: What can be learned from What is Contested’ (2015) 22(3) International Journal on Minority and Group Rights 387–409.

Human Rights Watch, ‘Abducted and Abused: Renewed Conflict in Northern Uganda’ (2003) 15(12A) Human Rights Watch 1–73.

International Bar Association (IBA) Commentary on the IBA Council ‘Rule of Law’ Resolution of September 2005 (IBA 2009).

International Crisis Group, Northern Uganda: Understanding and Solving the Conflict (ICG 2004).

Izama, A and Wilkerson, M, ‘Uganda: Museveni's Triumph and Weakness’ (2011) 22(3) Journal of Democracy 64–78.

Kinyanda, E, Musisi, S, Biryabarema, C, Ezati, I, Oboke, H, Ojiambo-Ochieng, R, Were-Oguttu, J, Levin, J, Grosskurth, H and Walugembe, J, ‘War-related Sexual Violence and its Medical and Psychological Consequences as seen in Kitgum, Northern Uganda: A Cross-sectional Study’ (2010) 10(28) BMC International Health and Human Rights 1–8.

Klinkner, M and Smith, E, ‘The Right to Truth, Appropriate Forum and the International Criminal Court’ in N Szblewska and S Bachmann (eds), Current Issues in Transitional Justice (Springer 2015) 3–29.

Koller, DS and Eckenfels-Garcia, M, ‘Using Targeted Sanctions to end Violations Against Children in Armed Conflict’ (2015) 33(1) Boston University International Law Journal 1–36.

Laplante, LJ, ‘On the Indivisibility of Rights: Truth Commissions, Reparations, and the Right to Development’ (2007) 10(1) Yale Human Rights & Development Law Journal 141–177.

Laruni, E, ‘Regional and Ethnic Identities: The Acholi of Northern Uganda, 1950–1968’ (2015) 9(2) Journal of Eastern African Studies 212–230.

Lawry-White, M, ‘The Reparative Effect of Truth Seeking in Transitional Justice’ (2015) 64(1) International and Comparative Law Quarterly 141–177.

Liebling, H, Davidson, L, Akello, GF and Ochola, G, ‘The Experiences of Survivors and Trauma Counselling Service Providers in Northern Uganda: Implications for Mental Health Policy and Legislation’ (2016) Sep–Dec 49(Pt A) International Journal of Law and Psychiatry 84–92.

Liebling-Kalifani, H, Marshall, A, Ojiambo-Ochieng R and Kakembo NM, ‘Experiences of Women War-torture Survivors in Uganda: Implications for Health and Human Rights’ (2013) 8(4) Journal of International Women's Studies 1–17. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijlp.2016.06.012.

Lodi, S, ‘The Mediterranean Sea and the Right to know about the Fate of Missing Relatives: Access to Justice for Families of Missing Migrants’ (2016) 3 SOAS Law Journal 103.

LRA ‘Crisis Tracker’. accessed 3 March 2016.

Lyons, T, ‘The Importance of Winning: Victorious Insurgent Groups and Authoritarian Politics’ (2016) 48(2) Comparative Politics 167–184.

McDonagh, M, ‘The Right to Information in International Human Rights Law’ (2013) 13(1) Human Rights Law Review 25–55.

McKnight, J, ‘Accountability in Northern Uganda: Understanding the Conflict, the Parties and the False Dichotomies in International Criminal Law and Transitional Justice’ (2015) 59(2) Journal of African Law 193–219.

McNamara, K, ‘Seeking Justice in Ugandan Courts: Amnesty and the Case of Thomas Kwoyelo’ (2013) 12(3) Washington University Global Studies Law Review 653.

Malu, LN, ‘The International Criminal Court and Conflict Transformation in Uganda: Views from the Field’ (2016) 15(2) African Journal on Conflict Resolution 81–103.

Mamdani, M, Imperialism and Fascism in Uganda (Heinemann 1983).

Mayanja, E, ‘Strengthening Ethical Political Leadership for Sustainable Peace and Social Justice in Africa: Uganda as a Case Study’ (2014) 13(2) African Journal on Conflict Resolution 113–146.

Mazimhaka, API, ‘Much to be done: Towards an Effective Transitional Justice Model for Dealing with Conflict-related Crimes of Sexual and Gender-Based Violence’ (Minor Dissertation, University of Cape Town 2014).

Mendeloff, D, ‘Truth-seeking, Truth-telling, and Post-conflict Peacebuilding: Curb the Enthusiasm?’ (2004) 6(3) International Studies Review 355–380.

Miller, Z, ‘Effects of Invisibility: In search of the Economic in Transitional Justice’ (2008) 2(3) International Journal of Transitional Justice 266–291.

Minow, M, ‘Forgiveness, Law, and Justice’ (2015) 103(6) California Law Review 1615.

Mutua, M, ‘Beyond Juba: Does Uganda need a National Truth and Reconciliation Process?’ (2007) 13(1) Buffalo Human Rights Law Review 401–414.

Nangoli, S, Ngoma, M, Kimbugwe, IW and Kituyi, M, ‘Towards enhancing Service Delivery in Uganda’s Local Government Units: Is Fiscal Decentralization Still a Feasible Strategy?’ (2015) 4(5) International Journal of Economics & Management Sciences 1–5.

Ndulo, MB and Duthie, R, ‘The Role of Judicial Reform in Development and Transitional Justice’ in P de Greiff and R Duthie (eds), Transitional Justice and Development: Making Connections (International Center for Transitional Justice 2009) 251.

Nouwen, SMH, Complementarity in the Line of Fire: The Catalysing Effect of the International Criminal Court in Uganda and Sudan. (Cambridge Studies in Law and Society 2013) 518–520. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511863264.

Okello, MC and Hovil, L, ‘Confronting the Reality of Gender-based Violence in Northern Uganda’ (2007) 3(1) International Journal of Transitional Justice 433–443.

Otim, M and Wierda, M, ‘Justice at Juba: International Obligations and Local Demands in Northern Uganda’ in N Waddell and P Clark (eds), Courting Conflict: Justice, Peace and the ICC in Africa (Royal African Society 2008) 21–29.

Otunnu, O, ‘Causes and Consequences of the War in Acholiland’ (2002) 11 Accord: An International Review of Peace Initiatives 10–15.

Perry, J and Sayndee, TB, African Truth Commissions and Transitional Justice (Lexington Books 2015).

Pham, PN, Vinck, P, Stover, E, Moss, A and Wierda, M, ‘When the War ends: A Population-Based Survey on Attitudes about Peace, Justice and Social Reconstruction in Northern Uganda’ (HRC, Payson CID, ICTJ 2007).

Quinn, JR, ‘Dealing with a Legacy of Mass Atrocity: Truth Commissions in Uganda and Chile’ (2001) 23(4) Netherlands Quarterly Human Rights 383–402.

Quinn, JR, ‘Constraints: The Undoing of the Ugandan Truth Commission’ (2004) 26(2) Human Rights Quarterly 401–427.

Quinn, JR, ‘Tradition?! Traditional Cultural Institutions on Customary Practices in Uganda’ (2014) 49(3) Africa Spectrum 29–54.

Quinn, JR, ‘The Impact of Internal Conflict on Customary Institutions and Law: The Case of Uganda’ (2015) 59(2) Journal of African Law 220–236.

Refugee Law Project, ‘Behind the Violence: Causes, Consequences and the Search for Solutions to the War in Northern Uganda’ (Refugee Law Project Working Paper 2004).

Refugee Law Project, ‘Is the PRDP Politics as Usual?’ (Refugee Law Project Uganda 2008).

Saile, R, Ertl, V, Neuner, F and Catani, C, ‘Does War contribute to Family Violence against Children? Findings from a Two-generational Multi-informant Study in Northern Uganda’ (2014) 38(1) Child Abuse & Neglect 135–146.

Sarkin, J, ‘The Need to deal with All Missing Persons including Those Missing as a Result of Armed Conflict, Disasters, Migration, Human Trafficking, and Human Rights Violations (including Enforced Disappearances) in International and Domestic Law and Processes’ (2005) 1 Inter-American and European Human Rights Journal 112–142.

Sarkin, J, ‘Achieving Reconciliation in Divided Societies: Comparing the Approaches in Timor-Leste, South Africa and Rwanda’ (2008) 3(2) Yale Journal of International Affairs 11–28.

Sarkin, J, ‘Enhancing the Legitimacy, Status and Role of the International Criminal Court by Using Transitional Justice or Restorative Justice Strategies’ (2011–2012) 6(1) Interdisciplinary Journal of Human Rights Law 83–102.

Sarkin, J, ‘Integrating Transitional Justice and Demobilisation, Disarmament and Reintegration: The Need to Achieve Rehabilitation, Reintegration and Reconciliation for Child Soldiers and Child Victims of Enforced Disappearances’ in I Derluyn, C Mels, S Parmentier and W Vandenhole (eds) Re-member: Rehabilitation and Reintegration of War-Affected Children (Intersentia 2012) 77–104.

Sarkin, J, ‘Providing Reparations in Uganda: Substantive Recommendations for implementing Reparations in the Aftermath of the Conflicts that occurred over the Last Few Decades’ (2014) 14(2) African Human Rights Law Journal 526–552.

Sarkin, J, ‘Should Reparations for Massive Human Rights Abuses perpetrated on African Victims during Colonial Times be given?’ in I Vanfraechem, A Pemberton and F Ndahinda (eds), Justice for Victims: Perspectives on Rights, Transition, and Reconciliation (Routledge 2014) 89–104.

Sarkin, J, ‘The Interrelationship and Interconnectness of Transitional Justice and the Rule of Law in Uganda: Pursuing Justice, Truth, Guarantees of Non-Repetition, Reconciliation and Reparations for Past Crimes and Human Rights Violations’ (2015) 7(1) Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 111–139.

Sarkin, J, ‘Understanding the Journey to Reconciliation in Transitional Societies: Using the Metaphor of a Motor Vehicle Road Trip to understand South Africa’s Path (Process) to Political Reconciliation’ (2015) 10(2) International Journal of Renaissance Studies 87–103.

Sarkin, J, ‘Ensuring Justice, Reparations and Truth through A Truth Commission and Other Processes in Uganda’ (2015) 3 Journal Law and Politics in Asia, Africa and Latin America 391–402.

Sarkin, J, ‘South Africa’s Reconciliation Process: Tools, Resources and Obstacles in the Journey to deal with Its Atrocious Past’ in A Frieberg and CKM Chung, Reconciling with the Past: Resources and Obstacles in a Global Perspective (Routledge 2017) 15–28.

Sengupta, S and Gladstone, R, ‘Fighter defects, citing Ties to the Fugitive African Warlord Joseph Kony’ The New York Times (New York, 6 January 2015).

Shanahan, F, ‘Cultural Responses to the Reintegration of Formerly Abducted Girl Soldiers in Northern Uganda’ (2008) 1(1) Psychology 14–28.

Skeels, A, ‘Refugee Children’s Participation in Protection: A Case Study from Uganda’, New Issues in Refugee Research (UNHCR 2012).

Souaré, IK, ‘Moving the Ugandan Peace Process from the Dichotomy of Criminal Trials vs Amnesty’ (2008) 17(2) African Security Review 106–112.

Ssenyonjo, M, ‘Accountability of Non-state Actors in Uganda for War Crimes and Human Rights Violations: Between Amnesty and the International Criminal Court’ (2005) 10(3) Journal of Conflict and Security Law 405–434.

The Survey for War Affected Youth (SWAY), ‘The State of Youth and Youth Protection in Northern Uganda: Findings from the Survey for War Affected Youth’ (UNICEF 2007) 26.

Tangri, R, ‘Politics, Donors and the Ineffectiveness of Anti-corruption Institutions in Uganda’ (2006) 44(1) The Journal of Modern African Studies 101–124.

Tangri, R and Mwenda, A, ‘Elite Corruption and Politics in Uganda’ (2008) 46(2) Commonwealth & Comparative Politics 177–194.

Thomas, DP and Gardner, R, ‘Restorative Justice in Post-conflict Northern Uganda: Exploring Reconciliation and Reconstruction through Transitional Justice Mechanisms’ (2014) 3(7) Online Journal of African Affairs 95–105.

Tiessen, R and Thomas, L, ‘Gendered Insecurity and the Enduring Impacts of Sexual and Gender-based Violence (SGBV) in Northern Uganda’ in D Buss, JM Lebert, BA Rutherford, D Sharkey and O Aginam (eds), Sexual Violence in Conflict and Post-Conflict Societies: International Agendas and African Contexts (Routledge 2014).

Tshimba, D-N, ‘Beyond the Mato Oput Tradition: Embedded Contestations in Transitional Justice for Post-massacre Pajong, Northern Uganda’ (2015) 2(2) Journal of African Conflicts and Peace Studies 62–85.

Tumushabe, J, ‘The Politics of HIV/AIDS in Uganda’ (United Nations Research Institute for Social Development 2006).

Uganda Police, ‘Annual Crime and Traffic/Road Safety Report’ (2011) accessed 25 December 2015.

UNESCO Education for All Global Monitoring Report, ‘The Hidden Crisis: Armed Conflict and Education’ (UNESCO 2011) 132.

UNICEF, ‘Review of UNICEF Supported Right to play Interventions in responding to the Psychosocial Needs of Children affected by Conflict in Northern and Eastern Uganda’ (UNICEF 2007).

United Nations, ‘Report of the United Nations Joint Human Rights Office on International Humanitarian Law Violations Committed by Allied Democratic Forces (ADF) Combatants in the Territory of Beni, North Kivu Province, Between 1 October and 31 December 2014’ (2015).

United Nations, ‘Uganda: Child Soldiers at Centre of Mounting Humanitarian Crisis’ in Ten Stories the World should hear More About (UNISVienna 2004).

United Nations, ‘UN Secretary-General’s Report: Children and Armed Conflict’ (2010).

United Nations OHCHR, ‘Making Peace Our Own: Victims’ Perceptions of Accountability, Reconciliation and Transitional Justice in Northern Uganda’ (United Nations 2007).

United Nations OHCHR, ‘The Dust has not Yet settled: Victims’ Views on the Right to Remedy and Reparation’ (2011).

United Nations Secretary-General’s Report, ‘A Life of Dignity for All: Accelerating Progress towards the Millennium Development Goals and advancing the United Nations Development Agenda Beyond 2015’ (UN 2013).

United Nations Security Council, ‘The Rule of Law and Transitional Justice in Conflict and Post Conflict Societies’ Report of the Secretary General (S/2004/616) (UNSG 2204).

United States Bureau of Democracy, ‘Human Rights, and Labor’ accessed 18 March 2016.

United States Department of State, ‘Trafficking in Persons Report – Uganda’ (2013)

accessed 3 March 2016.

Veale, A, McKay, S, Worthen, MN and Wessells, G, ‘Participation as Principle and Tool in Social Reintegration: Young Mothers Formerly Associated with Armed Groups in Sierra Leone, Liberia, and Northern Uganda’ (2013) 22(8) Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma 829–848.

Walakira, EJ and Ddumba-Nyanzi, I, ‘Violence against Children in Uganda: A Decade of Research and Practice, 2002–2012’ (Ministry of Gender Labour and Social Development and UNICEF 2012).

Waldorf, L, ‘Anticipating the Past Transitional Justice and Socio-economic Wrongs’ (2012) 21(2) Social & Legal Studies 171–186.

Walker, MU, ‘Truth Telling as Reparations’ (2010) 41(4) Metaphilosophy 525–545.

World Bank, World Development Report 2011 (WB 2011).




DOI: https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-6800/2957

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.