A Sign of the Times: South Africa’s Politico-legal Retrogression as illustrated through the Intention to withdraw from the Rome Statute
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.25159/2522-6800/2960Keywords:
Separation of powers, rule of law, political will, state sovereignty, International Criminal Court, international criminal law, enforcementAbstract
Sending the unequivocal message that perpetrators of crimes against humanity, genocide and war crimes would be prosecuted, South Africa was an active participant in the negotiations towards adopting the Rome Statute establishing the International Criminal Court (ICC). Indeed, South Africa was the 23rd state to ratify the treaty and domesticated it in the form of the Implementation of the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court Act 27 of 2002. Pursuant to the obligations undertaken by South Africa, it was incumbent on the state to arrest and surrender to the ICC the President of Sudan, Omar Al Bashir in June 2015, on the strength of two international arrest warrants issued against him by the ICC, when he attended the African Union Summit in South Africa. Instead, not only was Al Bashir’s sudden departure from South Africa facilitated by South African officials in contempt of a court order prohibiting same, but South Africa also deposited its instrument of withdrawal from the Rome Statute with the United Nations Secretary General soon afterwards. It is against this contextual background that South Africa’s failure to comply with the rule of law is assessed, with the evidence indicating that political considerations often outweigh legal obligations.
Metrics
References
African Union, Press Release on the Decisions of Pre-Trial Chamber I of the International Criminal Court, no 002/2012 (9 January 2012).
African Union Assembly, Decision on the Report of the Commission on the Abuse of the Principle of Universal Jurisdiction Doc. Assembly/AU/14(XI), para 5, Doc Assembly/AU/Dec.199(X) (June–July 2008).
African Union Peace and Security Council, Press Statement on its 141st Meeting, PSC/PR/BR(CXLI) (11 July 2008).
Akehurst M, A Modern Introduction to International Law (HarperCollins Academic 1982).
Alkoby, A, ‘Theories of Compliance with International Law and the Challenge of Cultural Difference’ (2008) 4(1) Journal of International Law and International Relations 165.
Alvarez, JE, ‘Do Liberal States behave Better? A Critique of Slaughter’s Liberal Theory’ (2001) 12 European Journal of International Law 183.
Benzing, M, ‘The Complementarity Regime of the International Criminal Court: International Criminal Justice between State Sovereignty and the Fight Against Impunity’ (2003) 7 Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law 592.
Beukes, M, ‘Southern African Events of International Significance—2007’ (2008) South African Yearbook of International Law 289.
Brown, W, Walled States, Waning Sovereignty (Zone Books 2010).
Burgstaller, M, Theories of Compliance with International Law (Brill Academic Publishers 2005).
Chayes, A and Chayes, A, The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements (Harvard University Press 1995).
Choudhry, S, ‘“He had a mandateâ€: The South African Constitutional Court and the African National Congress in a Dominant Party Democracy’ (2009) 2(1) Constitutional Court Review 1–86.
Cryer, R, Frimen, H, Robinson, D and Wilmshurst, E, An Introduction to International Criminal Law and Procedure (Cambridge University Press 2007). https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511801006
De Vos, P and Freedman, W (eds), South African Constitutional Law in Context (Oxford University Press 2014).
DIRCO, ‘Building a Better World: The Diplomacy of Ubuntu’, White Paper on South Africa’s Foreign Policy’, Final Draft 13 May 2011.
DIRCO, International Organizations, Treaties, Conventions and Declarations’, Department of International Relations and Co-operation (nd), .
D’Orsi, C, Asylum Seeker and Refugee Protection in Sub-Saharan Africa: The Peregrination of a Persecuted Human Being in Search of a Safe Haven (Routledge 2015).
Du Plessis, M, ‘South Africa’s Implementation of the ICC Statute: An African Example’ (2007) 5 Journal of International Criminal Justice 15.
Du Plessis, M, ‘A Chinese Vessel in Durban with Weapons destined for Zimbabwe’ (2008) 33 South African Yearbook of International Law 267.
Du Plessis, M and Mettraux, G, ‘South Africa’s Failed Withdrawal from the Rome Statute: Politics, Law and Judicial Accountability’ (2017) Journal of International Criminal Justice 10.
Editorial Staff, ‘UK regrets The Gambia’s withdrawal from Commonwealth’ BBC News (London, 3 October 2013), .
Editorial Staff, ‘Profile: Sudan Omar al-Bashir’ BBC News (London), .
Editorial Staff, ‘Gambian Youth Flee Bleak Future at Home’, Deutsche Welle (Bonn), <http://www.dw.de/gambian-youth-flee-bleak-future-at-home/a-18414345>.
Elvy, SA, ‘Theories of State Compliance with International Law: Assessing the African Union’s Ability to ensure Compliance with the African Charter and Constitutive Act’ (2012) 41 Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law 75.
Freedman, R, Failing to Protect: The UN and the Politicisation of Human Rights (C Hurst & Co 2014).
Goodman, R and Jinks, C, ‘Towards an Institutional Theory of Sovereignty’ (2003) 55 Stanford Law Review 1762.
Graham, SE, ‘South Africa’s Voting Behaviour in the United Nations, 1994–2008’ (PhD thesis, University of Johannesburg 2013) 263.
Guest, R, The Shackled Continent: Africa’s Past, Present and Future (Pan Books 2004).
Habib, A, South Africa’s Suspended Revolution: Hopes and Prospects (Wits University Press 2013).
Henkin, L, How Nations Behave (2 edn, Columbia University Press 1979).
Henwood, R, ‘South Africa’s Foreign Policy’ (2005) South African Yearbook of International Law 302–303.
Human Dignity Trust Report (nd), .
International Justice Resource Centre, ‘African Union Approves Immunity for Governmental Officials in Amendment to African Court of Justice and Human Rights’ Statute’ (2 July 2014) .
Kennedy, D, ‘The Disciplines of International Law and Policy’ (1999) 9 Leiden Journal of International Law 133.
Koskenniemi, M, From Apology to Utopia: The Structure of International Legal Argument (Finnish Lawyers’ Publishing 1989).
Kostiner, I, ‘Evaluating Legality: Toward a Cultural Approach to the Study of Law and Social Change’ (2003) 37 Law and Society Review 323.
Kratochwil, F, ‘The Force of Prescriptions’ (1984) 38 International Organizations 690.
Langa, P, ‘Statement in Support of the Complaint to the Judicial Service Commission by the Judges of the Constitutional Court made on 30 May 2008’ (2008) <http://www.politicsweb.co.za/politicsweb/view/politicsweb/en/page71656?oid=92275&sn=Detail>.
Lazarev, MI, ‘On a Theoretical Concept of Control Over the Fulfilment of International Obligations of States’ in WE Butler (ed), Control over Compliance with International Law (Martinus Nijhoff 1991) 17.
Leary, V, International Labour Conventions and National Law (Martinus Nijhoff 1982). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-017-6804-7
Lewis, C, UNHCR and International Refugee Law: From Treaties to Innovation (Routledge 2012).
Magnarella PJ, ‘Assessing the Concept of Human Rights in Africa’ (2001) 1 Journal of Human Rights and Human Welfare 25.
Mandela, N, ‘South Africa’s Future Foreign Policy’ (1993) 72(5) Foreign Affairs 86.
Mbazira, C, ‘Confronting the Problem of Polycentricity in Enforcing Socio-economic Rights in the South African Constitution’ (2008) 23 Southern African Public Law 30.
Mbeki, T, ‘Statement on behalf of the African National Congress, on the occasion of the adoption by the Constitutional Assembly of the Republic of South Africa Constitutional Bill 1996’ (8 May 1996) in T Mbeki, Africa: The Time Has Come, Selected Speeches by Thabo Mbeki (Tafelberg 1998).
Mokgoro, YM, ‘Ubuntu and the Law in South Africa’ (1988) 4 Buffalo Human Rights Law Review 15–23.
Neumayer, E, ‘Do International Human Rights Treaties Improve Respect for Human Rights?’ (2005) 49(6) The Journal of Conflict Resolution 952.
Newton, M, ‘Comparative Complementarity: Domestic Jurisdiction Consistent with the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court’ (2001) 167 Military Law Review 20, 26.
Nguyen, K, ‘Fleeing Burundi, Children as Young as Six arrive Alone in Camps: Charity’ Thomson Reuters Foundation (London, 5 June 2015) .
Nichols, M, ‘SA begins process to withdraw from International Criminal Court’ Mail & Guardian (Johannesburg, 21 October 2016) .
Nkoana-Mashabane, M, ‘Lecture by the Minister of International Relations and Cooperation’ (Rhodes University, Grahamstown, 22 October 2009).
Olugbuo, B, ‘Positive Complementarity and the Fight against Impunity in Africa’ in Murungu CB and Biegon J, Prosecuting International Crimes in Africa (Pretoria University Law Press 2009) 250–251.
Pollis, A, ‘Cultural Relativism Revisited: Through a State Prism’ (1996) 18 Human Rights Quarterly 324.
Pound, R, ‘The Scope and Purpose of Socio-Logical Jurisprudence’ (1912) 25(6) Harvard Law Review 514–516.
Powell, C, ‘United States Human Rights Policy in the 21st Century in an Age of Multilateralism’ (2002) 46 St Louis University Law Journal 421.
Raborife, M, ‘ANC wants SA to withdraw from the ICC’ News24 (Johannesburg) <http://www.news24.com>.
Raustiala, K and Slaughter, A, ‘International Law, International Relations and Compliance’ in W Carlsnaes, T Risse and BA Simmons (eds), Handbook of International Relations (SAGE 2002) 538. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781848608290.n28
Schabas, WA, An Introduction to the International Criminal Court (4 edn, Cambridge University Press 2011).
Shklar, JN, Legalism: Law, Morals, and Political Trials (Harvard University Press 1986).
Spies, Y, ‘South Africa’s Foreign Policy’ (2009) South African Yearbook of International Law 271.
Spies, Y, ‘South Africa’s Foreign Policy’ (2011) South African Yearbook of International Law 327.
Slaughter, AM, ‘International Law in a World of Liberal States’ (1985) 3 European Journal of International Law 503.
Steiner, H, Alston, P and Goodman, R, International Human Rights in Context: Law, Politics, Morals (Oxford University Press 2008).
Stone, L, ‘Implementation of the Rome Statute in South Africa’ in C Murungu and J Biegon (eds), Prosecuting International Crimes in Africa (Pretoria University Law Press 2011) 305.
Van Wyk, JAK, ‘South Africa’s Post-apartheid Foreign Policy: A Constructivist Analysis’ (2004) 23(3) Politeia 109.
Viljoen, F, International Human Rights Law in Africa (2 edn, Oxford University Press 2012).
Cases
Bishop Rubin Phillip & Another v National Conventional Arms Control Committee & Others Durban and Coast Local Division, High Court, Order granted 18 April 2008.
De Lange v Smuts NO & Others 1998 (3) SA 785 (CC).
Democratic Alliance v Minister of International Relations and Cooperation & Others (Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution Intervening) (case no 83145/2016) [2017] ZAGPPHC 53 (22 February 2017).
Doctors for Life International v Speaker of the National Assembly & Others 2006 (12) BCLR 1399 (CC).
Glenister v President of the Republic of South Africa & Others (Glenister II) 2011 (3) SA 347 (CC).
Masethla v President of the Republic of South Africa & Another 2008 (1) BCLR 1 (CC).
Matatiele Municipality & Others v President of the Republic of South Africa & Others 2006 (5) BCLR 622 (CC).
Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association of SA & Another: In re Ex Parte President of the Republic of South Africa & Others [2000] ZACC 1; 2000 (2) SA 674 (CC).
Prince v South Africa (2004) AHRLR 105 (ACHPR 2004).
The Prosecutor v Omar Hassan Al Bashir, Decision on the Prosecution’s Application for a Warrant of Arrest against Omar Hassan Al Bashir, case no ICC-02/05-01/09.
South African Association of Personal Injury Lawyers v Heath & Others 2001 (1) BCLR 77 (CC).
The Southern Africa Litigation Centre v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development & Others (case no 27740/2015) [2015] ZAGPPHC (23 June 2015).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Accepted 2017-08-16
Published 2018-10-09
