AGSA, VROU VAN OTNIËL

  • Magdel le Roux University of South Africa

Abstract

Die literêre uitbeelding van die verhale in die boek Rigters weerspieël ʼn korporatiewe eenheid van stamme of sibbes waarin individue ook ʼn prominente rol speel. Binne die stammeorganisasie kan verwag word dat dié individue tipiese “ideale liggame†– heel manlike Israeliete – sal wees. In teenstelling daarmee speel “nie-ideale liggame†soos vroue, “gestremdes†en “heidene†ʼn toonaangewende rol in die boek. Die naasmekaarstelling van “ideale†en “nie-ideale liggame†in die boek skep beide spanning en ironie, veral wanneer die “nie-ideale vroulike liggaam†inisiatief neem terwyl die ideale manlike Israeliet dikwels ʼn bedreiging skep wat op skade of skande uitloop (bv Rgt 14–16). Die rol wat Agsa in Rigters 1:11–15 speel is ʼn illustrasie van ʼn “teenkultuur-retoriek†as verskuilde polemiek (vgl ook 4–5; 9:50; 11:37–40; 13).

 

The literary depiction of this story in the book of Judges reflects a corporate unit of tribes or clans in which individuals played a prominent role. Within the tribal organisation these individuals could be expected to have typical “ideal bodies†– entirely masculine Israelites. “Non-ideal bodiesâ€, such as women, the handicapped and heathens, in contrast, play a leading role in the book. The juxtaposition of the “ideal†and the “non-ideal body†in Judges creates both tension and irony, especially when the “non-ideal female body†takes the initiative, while the ideal manly Israelite often creates a threat that results in harm or shame (e.g. Judges 14–16). The role Achsah plays in Judges 1:11–15 is an illustration of a counter-culture rhetoric as hidden polemic (cf also 4–5; 9:50; 11:37–40; 13).



References

Ackermann, S 1998. Warrior, dancer, seductress, queen. Women in Judges and biblical Israel. London: Doubleday.

_______ 2003. Digging up Deborah: Recent Hebrew Bible scholarship on gender and the contribution of archaeology, in Near Eastern Archaeology 66/4 (Dec 2003). The American Schools of Oriental Research, 172–184. Available: http://www.jstor.org/stable/3557917 [Accessed 2014/05/27].

Amit, Y 2000. Hidden polemics in Biblical narrative (transl Chipman, J). Biblical Interpretation Series 25. Leiden: Brill.

Berquist, J L 2002. Controlling corporeality. The body and the household in ancient Israel. New Brunswick: New Jersey.

Christ, C 2013. Patriarchy as a system of male dominance created at the intersection of the control of women, private and war, Part I. Available: http:/feminismandreligion.com/2013/02/18/patriarchy-as-an-integral-system-of-male-dominance-created-at-the-intersection-of-the-control-of women-private-property-and-war-part-1-by-carol-p-christ/ [Accessed 2015/05/20].

Cook, S 1915. The significance of the Elephantine Papyri for the history of Hebrew religion, The American Journal of Theology 19/3:346–382.

Cundall, A E 1968. Judges. An introduction and commentary, in Wiseman 1968:11–215.

Davies, P R 1992. In search of ancient Israel. Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press.

Fewell, D N 1995. Deconstructive criticism: Achsah and the (e)razed city of writing in Yee 1995:125–145.

Frymer-Kensky, T 2006. Studies in Bible and feminist criticism. JPS Scholar Distinction Series. Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society.

Graybill, R 2015. Gender and the Hebrew Bible, in Oxford Biblical Studies Online. Available: http://www.oxfordbiblicalstudies.com/resource/gender_hb.xhtml [Accessed 2015/05/20].

Hammer, J 2004. Sisters at Sinai. New tales of biblical women. Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society.

Harris, G J, Brown, C A & Moore, M S 2000. New international biblical commentary. Joshua, Judges, Ruth. Peabody: Hendrickson.

Klein, L R 1988. The triumph of irony in the Book of Judges. Journal for the study of the Old Testament supplement series, 68. Sheffield: Almond.

Korpel, M 2008. Fit for a Queen: Jezebel’s royal seal. Available: http://www.crossway.org/blog/2014/08/does-the-bible-reflect-a-patriarchal-bias [Accessed 2015/05/20].

Kraft, C F et al. (eds) 1967. Judges, Samuel 1 and 11. The illustrated family encyclopedia of the living Bible, Vol 4. Chicago: American Book-Stratford.

LaCocque, A 1990. The feminine unconventional: Four subversive figures in Israel’s tradition.

Lübbe, J C 2010. The Danite invasion of Laish and the purpose of the Book of Judges, OTE 23/3:681–692.

Matthews, V H 2004. Judges and Ruth. The new Cambridge Bible commentary. Cambridge: University Press.

Malina, B 2001. The New Testament world: insights from cultural anthropology. Louisville: John Knox.

McCann, J C 2002. Judges. A Bible Commentary for Teaching and Preaching. Louisville: John Knox.

Meyers, C 1998. Everyday life: Women in the period of the Hebrew Bible, in Newsom and Ringe 1998:251–262.

Newsom, C and Ringe, S (eds) 1998. Women’s Bible commentary. Louisville Kentucky: Westminster John Knox Press.

Porten, B [sa]. Elephantine. Available http://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/elephantine [Accessed 2015/03/07].

Robbins, V K 1996. Exploring the texture of texts: A guide to socio-rhetorical interpretation. Pennsylvania: Trinity.

Sivan, H 2004. Between woman, man and God: A new interpretation of the Ten Commandments. London: T & T Clark.

Sternberg, M 1987. The poetics of biblical narrative. Ideological literature and the drama of reading. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.

Van der Merwe, N C 2009. The identification of whole and unwhole bodies in the book of Judges. Unpublished DLitt et Phil thesis, University of Johannesburg.

Van der Merwe, N C & Coetzee, J H 2009. An alternative ideology relating to difference as hidden polemic in the book of Judges: Judges 4–5 as an illustration, OTE 22/3:677–694.

Wiseman, D J 1968. The Tyndale Old Testament commentaries. Judges and Ruth. London: Tyndale.

Yee, G A (ed.) 1995. Judges and method. New approaches in biblical Studies. Minneapolis: Fortress.

Zerzan, J 2010. Patriarchy, civilization and the origins of gender. Available: theanarchistlibrary.org/library/john-zervan-patriarchy-civilization-and-the-origins-of-gender [Accessed 2015/02/16].

Published
2017-11-17
Section
Articles