Login to access subscriber-only resources.
Focus and Scope
SAPL aims to provide academics and intellectuals from Southern Africa and Africa in general a forum for discursive deliberation and debate on matters relating to public law. The journal welcomes contributions dealing with topics in constitutional and administrative law, legal philosophy, legal and constitutional theory, law and government law and closely related fields. The journal encourages a multiâ€“, inter-, and transdisciplinary approach to these various facets of public law. The journal also welcomes book reviews on topical subjects in the field of public law.
Peer Review Process
All submissions are peer-reviewed by means of the double blind system to guarantee impartiality and a focus on quality of the submissions. All articles submitted to the journal are peer reviewed by at least two reviewers.
The final decision in the case of a dispute between reviewers lies with the editors, although in all cases an attempt is made to reach consensus between the reviewers.
Oxford University Standard for the Citation of Legal Authorities (OSCOLA)
When a style is proposed, it does not intend to suggest that other styles are incorrect. It is, however, an endeavour to achieve a standardised typographical style and consistent language choices. The main objective is to make it easier for authors, editors, copyeditors, layout editors and all those who publish, to know what choices to make in the myriad of existing options. The University of South Africaâ€™s Department of Public, Constitutional and International Law uses the OSCOLA guide to citation (fourth edition) (https://www.law.ox.ac.uk/) together with New Hartâ€™s Rules: The Oxford Style Guide (second edition 2014).
The style guide focuses on two major aspects:
1) Guidelines for technical preparation;
2) Citation guidelines.
1. Â Â Guidelines for technical preparation of manuscript
- Submit manuscripts electronicallyâ€”MS Word file.
- All graphic material has to be positioned at the correct place in the text. Do not add supplementary files with graphic content.
- Manuscripts must be presented as: A4 pages; normal margins; 12pt Times Roman; 1.5 line spacing.
- Proofing language must be set as UK English (colourâ€”not color; travelledâ€”not travelled; organise; organisation; organisingâ€”not -ize).
- Do not type double spaces anywhere; between words, at the end of sentences or after colons.
- Type hard spaces (shift + control + space bar) when phrases are preferred to be presented as a unit, e.g.10_000; Vol 1 (2):_22âˆ’21.
- Articles should not exceed 8 000 words. Case notes, journal notes and book reviews should not exceed 3 000 words.
- Make sure you follow the guidelines for ensuring a blind peer review for the particular submission system the journal uses.
- Present an indented abstract of not more than 250 words. Abstracts should not contain any footnotes or citations. Do not type the abstract in italics.
- Below the abstract, please provide 5â€“8 keywords for indexing (only proper nouns in capitals). Distinguish between keywords/phrases with a semicolon, e.g. business law harmonisation; CISG; Commercial Uniform Act; OHADA law; uniform sales law
- Authors should include their affiliation or ORCID below their name, after the title of the article.
- For case notes the authorâ€™s name and affiliation is also placed after the title.
- For book reviews the format and order of information is as follows:
<Book title in italics>
<Book author name(s) and surname>
<Publisher, date and number of pages>
- Do not use an asterisk (*) or other symbols as footnotes containing biographical information. Start footnotes with the number 1.
- Avoid ampersands except in established combinations (e.g. R & B) and in names of firms that use them (Mail & Guardian). The use of ampersands in case names is acceptable: Chairperson of the Immigration Selection Board v Frank & Another.
- In text, emphasise words by using italics only sparingly. Italicisation should otherwise be reserved for titles and words from a language other than that of the text. Latin/foreign words and phrases that are common in legal English are set in roman, for example, de jure, stare decisis, obiter dicta, ratio decidendi, a priori, prima face, inter-alia, dictum and dicta.
- Italicised words/phrases in another language are glossed by an equivalent word/phrase in the language of the text in single inverted commas placed in brackets, e.g. â€¦Indoda (â€˜a manâ€™). Words well-known in South African English are set as roman, for example, lobola, ubuntu, indaba.
- The names of parties in case names are cited in italics, separated by an italic â€˜vâ€™ with no full point.
- Words/terms that need to be singled out as being â€˜borrowedâ€™ from another author/source may be placed in single inverted commas.
- The names of books and non-law journals and reports should be in italic. Abbreviated references to reports and reviews should be in roman. Full names of law journals and reports are in roman (see OSCOLA).
- Acknowledgements should be brief and recognise sources of financial and logistical support and permission to reproduce materials from other sources. Enclose a copy of documentation granting such permission. Adherence to copyright rules remains each authorâ€™s sole responsibility.
- When quoting from a source, use â€˜single inverted commasâ€™.
- To quote within a quote, use â€œdouble inverted commasâ€.
- When quoting more than five lines, indent. Do not print indented text in italics and do not use quotation marks. Place indented quotes in 10 pt Times Roman.
- When quoting within an indented quotation, use single inverted commas.
- Commas and full points are set inside the closing quotation mark regardless of whether they are part of the quoted material.
- When the quoted sentence ends with a question mark or exclamation mark, this should be placed within the closing quotation mark, with no other mark outside the quotation mark.
- When a quoted sentence is a short one with no introductory punctuation, the full point is generally placed outside the closing quotation mark:
Hereafter â€˜SALC reportâ€™.
- When adding notes to a quote or changing a quotation, use square brackets, e.g. [own translation/ emphasis]/[t]oday.
- Oxford style is to use words for numbers below 100. At the start of a sentence all numbers are in words.
- Use figures for ages expressed in cardinal numbers, and words for ages expressed as ordinal numbers or decades:
girl of 15 Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â a 33-year-old man
between her teens and twenties Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â in his thirty-third year
in the twenty-first century
- In brackets all numbers are in digits, as for numbers of tables, figures and chapters.
- Note that per cent rather than % is used in running text. Decimal fractions are always printed in figures. They cannot be plural, or take a plural verb.
- The letters in ordinal numbers should not appear as superscripts (e.g. 122nd and NOT 122nd).
- References to decades may be made in either words or figures: â€˜the sixtiesâ€™ or â€˜the 1960sâ€™, not â€˜the â€™60sâ€™.
- Oxford style is to use words to refer to centuries; â€˜the nineteenth centuryâ€™.
- Figures are used for days and years in dates. Use cardinal numbers not ordinal numbers for dates:
12 August 1960 Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â 2 November 2003
Abbreviations and acronyms
- Abbreviations that begin and end on the same letter as the word do not get a full stop (Mr/Dr/Eds) but Prof./Ed.
- Degrees: (Preferably without any punctuation)
BProc; LLB; LLM; BA; DPhil; MSc
- Spell out abbreviations at first mention, adding the abbreviation in parentheses after it:
University of South Africa (Unisa).
- The use of abbreviations in footnotes is encouraged (consult OSCOLA).
- An ellipsis is a series of points signalling that words have been omitted from quoted matter.
- Insert a normal word space before and after the ellipse.
- An ellipsis at the end of an incomplete sentence is not followed by a fourth full point.
- A comma immediately before or after an ellipsis can be omitted.
- Sentences ending with a question mark or exclamation mark retain these marks before or after the ellipsis:
Could we â€¦?
Could we do it? â€¦ It might just be possible â€¦!
- Use the en rule (â€“) [Alt+0150] closed up in elements that form a range:
Page numbers 23â€“36; dates 1939â€“45
- The en rule is used closed up to express connection or relation between words; it means roughly â€˜toâ€™ or â€˜andâ€™:
- The em rule (â€”) [Alt+0151] is used closed up as a parenthetical dash. No punctuation should precede a single dash or the opening one of a pair. Do not capitalize a word, other than a proper noun, after a dash, even if it begins a sentence.
- Proper nouns and initials are capitalised (omit the full points and spaces):
- In British English, matter following a colon begins with a lower-case initial, unless it is a displayed quotation or extract.
- Capitalise the names of institutions, organisations, societies, movements, and groups:
the World BankÂ Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â the House of Lords
the United Nations
- Capitalise â€˜Articleâ€™ when it refers to supranational legislation e.g. conventions and treaties. Write â€˜articleâ€™ in lower case when it refers to national legislation. The word â€˜sectionâ€™ is always lower case.
- Capitalise historical periods and geological time scales:
the Dark AgesÂ Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â the Renaissance
- Capitalisation of work titles (article titles for submission as well as titles of all cited works in footnotes):
Oxford style is to give maximal capitalisation to titles of works. Capitalise the first letter of the first word and all other important words. Nouns, adjectives and verbs are capitalised. Pronouns and adverbs are capitalised. Articles, conjunctions and prepositions are left uncapitalised.
- Footnotes with references in Arabic numbers (1,2,3) are allowed (do not use i,ii,iii).
- Footnotes are typed in 9pt Times Roman font and single spacing; hanging indent 6mm.
- Endnotes are not allowed.
- Refer to citation guidelines for footnotes on the OSCOLA style guide.
- Footnote numbers are preferably placed at the end of a clause, and after any punctuation (with the exception of the dash).
- The number normally follows a quotation. Relative to other punctuation, the number follows any punctuation mark except for the dash, which it precedes. Examples are:
â€˜This,â€™ wrote George Templeton Strong, â€˜is what our tailors can do.â€™1
The bias was apparent in the Shotwell series2 â€”and it must be remembered that Shotwell was a student of Robinsonâ€™s.
- Though a note number normally follows a closing parenthesis, it may on rare occasion be more appropriate to place the number inside the closing parenthesisâ€”if, for example, the note applies to a specific term within the parentheses. Examples are:
(In an earlier book he had said quite the opposite.)3
Men and their unions, as they entered industrial work, negotiated two things: young women would be laid off once they married (the commonly acknowledged â€˜marriage barâ€™4), and men would be paid a â€˜family wage.â€™
- Close footnotes with a full stop.
2. Â Â Citation guidelines: OSCOLA
- Within the body of your text, footnotes are inserted as numbered notes that appear at the bottom of each page of your paper.
- Use Arabic numbers 1,2,3, not Roman onesâ€”i,ii,iii.
- For the first footnote, insert a numeral and the system will continue numbering in this manner. Do not use superscript font within the footnote entry.
- Citing cases
When citing cases, give the name of the case, the neutral citation, and volume and first page of the relevant law report, and the court. In South African jurisdiction, cases are cited as follows:
<names of the parties in italics><year of the law report in which case is published>(<volume>)<reporter><page on which the case begins>(<court>) <page>
Fraser v Naude & Others 1999 (1) SA 1 (CC) 78
- Subsequent citations and cross-references
In a subsequent citation of a source, briefly identify the source and provide a cross-citation in brackets to the footnote in which the full citation can be found:
Fraser (n 21)
- Use â€˜ibidâ€™ for subsequent citations in footnotes immediately following the full citation.
- Abbreviations â€˜ibidâ€™ and â€˜cfâ€™ are not capitalised.
1 Iain Currie and Johan de Waal, The Bill of Rights Handbook (Juta 2014) 250.
3 cf S v Khan 1997 (2) SACR 611 (SCA).
- References to notes are placed between parentheses in the footnotes e.g. (n 21).
- Avoid using Latin gadgets such as supra, infra, ante, id, op cit, loc cit and contra, which are not widely understood.
- Use as little punctuation as possible. Abbreviations, acronyms and initials in authorâ€™s names do not take full stops:
Malcolm v DPP  EWHC 363 (Admin),  1 WLR 1230
- Define unfamiliar abbreviations in a footnote. Do not define abbreviations that are part of everyday legal usage, such as â€˜DPPâ€™. See OSCOLA s 4.2 for list of abbreviations.
- Judgeâ€™s namesâ€”where reference is made to a judge in a case, use the judgeâ€™s surname followed by the conventional abbreviation identifying their judicial office. Do not use honorifics such as â€˜the Honourableâ€™: Mr/Mrs Justice Smithâ€™ in text and â€˜Smith Jâ€™ in footnote.
The title and number of a statute should not be italicised, except where the statute is used as a foreign statute in a different language, for example the Internal Security Act 74 1982, but Bundesbeamptengesetz.
Titles of articles appear in single inverted commas, for example AJGM Sanders, â€˜How Customary is African Customary Law?â€™ (1987) XX 3 CILSA 412â€“415.
First name and surname followed by a comma.
More than one author use â€œandâ€, e.g. John Ross and Margaret Taylor, thereafter in footnotes cite only the surname of the first author with a pinpoint to the appropriate note e.g. Ross (n 3).
Titles of books are italicised and written in significant capitals. For example, Anthony Mathews, Freedom, State Security and the Rule of Law (UCP 1986).
Editions â€“ omit abbreviations â€˜ndâ€™ and â€˜thâ€™ â€“ write together in brackets with year of publication e.g. (2 edn 1990).
Titles of journals are in roman. Recognised abbreviations of South African journals are used (e.g. SAJHR, SALJ, THRHR and CILSA), but the titles of foreign journals are quoted in full (except for common abbreviations like Univ, LR and LJâ€”e.g. Univ Pennsylvania LR; Yale LJ).
Journal articles should ideally be referenced as follows:
AJGM Sanders, â€˜How Customary is African Customary Law?â€™ (1987) XX 3 CILSA 412â€“415.
[Author, â€˜titleâ€™ (year) volume journal name or abbreviation quoted page of article]
Page numbersâ€”where not confusing use only number but where necessary use â€˜atâ€™.
- Newspapers articles
Titles of newspapers are italicised. Titles of articles are placed in single quotation marks. The city of publication and the date is placed in brackets.
Mpho Raborife, â€˜State of the City wrap: Mashaba vows to focus on Joburgâ€™s â€œforgotten peopleâ€â€™ Mail & Guardian (Johannesburg, 4 May 2017) 1.
- Internet references
Author, â€˜titleâ€™ (website, date of publication) <url> accessed 4 May 2017.
Do not underline the url.
Mpho Raborife, â€˜State of the City wrap: Mashaba vows to focus on Joburgâ€™s â€œforgotten peopleâ€â€™ (Mail & Guardian, 4 May 2017) <https://mg.co.za/article/2017-05-04-mashaba-vows-to-focus-on-joburgs-forgotten-people> accessed 4 May 2017.
- Thesis and dissertation
When citing an unpublished thesis, give the author, the title and then in brackets the type of thesis, university and year of completion:
Javan Herberg, â€˜Injunctive Relief for Wrongful Termination of Employmentâ€™ (DPhil thesis, University of Oxford 1989).
Consult OSCOLA for a comprehensive guide on citing sources in footnotes.
Items in bibliographies take the same form as all other citations in OSCOLA, with three exceptions: (1) the authorâ€™s surname should precede his or her initial(s), with no comma separating them, but a comma after the final initial; (2) only initials should be used, and not forenames; and (3) the titles of unattributed works should be preceded by a double em-dash. Works should be arranged in alphabetical order of author surname, with unattributed works being listed at the beginning of the bibliography in alphabetical order of first major word of the title.
- Citation in bibliography:
Mathews A, Freedom, State Security and the Rule of Law (UCP 1986).
- Books, journals, newspaper articles, theses and dissertations are cited in the list of references under the heading â€˜Referencesâ€™.
- Cases are then cited under the heading â€˜Casesâ€™.
- All legislation is cited in full under the heading â€˜Legislationâ€™.
Consult OSCOLA and Hartâ€™s Rules for a comprehensive guide on citing sources in a bibliography.
Â Â authorÂ canÂ archive pre-print (ie pre-refereeing)
Â Â authorÂ canÂ archive post-print (ie final accepted version post-refereeing)
Â Â authorÂ cannotÂ archive publisher's version/PDF